Starting university in autumn 2007 propelled me back into the mainstream when it came to music; for a few years prior to that I was hardly aware of anything outside of my very selective listening habits, chasing links across the internet and bands across the country, browsing CDs and relying upon word-of-mouth or reliable music writing to find new and interesting music. My re-induction into mainstream pop has produced a variety of listening experiences, both good and bad, enduring and fleeting. Overall, though, I don’t regret it, and Ten Pop, Ten Not is a tribute to the typical two-pronged listening habits that I have fallen into over the past few years. Ten songs that are pure pop, ten that are… not.
Obviously I abuse the term ‘pop’ – half of the ‘not’ list are arguably pop in some form or other, but I wanted to distinguish between the sort radio-friendly music I was oblivious to a few years ago, and the other sort of music that I suppose I would have listened to last year anyway. Quibble all you like, but it’s a nice title, okay? Plus this way I get to pick two top tens.
The guidelines are as follows – the song had to be released in the UK between 1st Jan and 31st December 2009 (a rule which complicated matters hugely because of downloads and hearing songs in clubs and all that jazz). One song per band. If it’s an album track the album must have come out in 2009 in the UK, if it’s a single then it must have been released in 2009. The thinking here is that list-compiling would be so much more difficult it I had to pick from all the songs I’ve loved this year, regardless of when they were released.
I’ve included Youtube links to each song, and compiled as complete a Spotify playlist as possible, which is available at the end of the post. Enjoy!
Ten Pop
10. Get Sexy – Sugababes
It is, of course, the last ever true Sugababes song and whilst the Right Said Fred sampling is a little suspect, and the lyrics leave something to be desired, sometimes that just doesn’t matter. It certainly doesn’t when there’s as many attitude power-ups and consistently satisfying ‘dancey-bits’ as there are here.
9. Beyonce – Single Ladies (Put a Ring on It)
It’s no Crazy In Love, but Single Ladies definitely hung out in the same gang at school and went for sleep-overs at Crazy In Love’s house. I have little time for Beyonce’s ballads but I do admit that every year since 2003 I have felt a Crazy In Love-shaped gap in my life. What else but Beyonce’s particular brand of feist could fill it?
8. Riverside – Sidney Samson
Riverside, Motherfucker!
7. Holiday – Dizzee Rascal
This trundles along in a fairly unremarkable way until the very end, where the underlying synth-edged beats break free and wreak havoc upon all that has gone before. The genius of Holiday is perhaps that restraint and moderation – it lacks the explosive immediacy of Bonkers, and works better because of that. Bonkers is a binge of ‘electro-hop’ that leaves you feeling a bit greasy and regretful. Holiday is a short, sharp, addictive hit of synth-pop-meets-grime, the all-too-short climax begging a repeat play as it is just not long enough.
6. Ready for the Weekend – Calvin Harris
This song never fails to make me feel ready for the weekend.
5. Remedy – Little Boots
This just feels so confident and effortless. I have heard a lot of love directed at New In Town but I find something about this little pop gem very compelling. It is very much a song to play loudly as you drink too much vodka and dance in your housemate’s bedroom before launching out into the night. It also helps that it allows me to almost credibly yell ‘Yes, dancing IS my remedy!’ mid-song. Almost.
4. Drumming Song – Florence + The Machine
My housemate adores Florence and her musical output. Consequently I spent much of 2009 unwittingly absorbing demos and covers and live versions and finally the album proper. Nothing really stuck until Drumming Song – there’s something a little bit delicious about the interplay between pounding drums and soaring vocals here, Florence darting between ritualistic chanting and hypnotic crooning, refusing to settle for a straightforward structure or predictable pattern. It works.
3. Bulletproof – La Roux
A song for dancing to. In For The Kill is a close second, but as ice-cool and retro-futuristic as that song may be, Bulletproof pops and bounces like nobody’s business and doesn’t leave you feeling a bit self-conscious and high-pitched two minutes in.
2. Boom Boom Pow – Black Eyed Peas
‘Here we go, here we go, satellite, radio, y’all getting hit with the BOOM BOOM.’
No, I don’t know what it means. Yes, I’m far too white and geeky to pull it off. But for weeks this song fuelled and soundtracked my every move. I am a sucker for those beats.
1. Bad Romance – Lady Gaga
It should be Poker Face. Hell, it was Poker Face for the majority of the year. Beats and synths layered in perfect combination, vocals snapping back and forth between defiance and ridiculousness. Pure Lady Gaga. But then came Bad Romance.
Bad Romance is mental. No longer a mere alter-ego, Lady Gaga eats Stefani Germanotta and spits out the bones. Everything about Bad Romance seizes the mythology of ‘Lady Gaga’ and transfigures it into reality. Just Dance was Gaga setting out, Poker Face was Gaga proving more than a one hit wonder, Paparazzi was Gaga’s manifesto outright and LoveGame was Gaga, well, talking about sex. Bad Romance is Lady Gaga sounding more like how Lady Gaga should sound than ever before. It’s a potent popstar that can produce such a natural-sounding musical progression in their fifth single in two years.
I could go on about the song’s bizarre intro, I could hold forth on how Gaga invokes Andy Warhol, Liza Minelli-in-Cabaret, Vogue-era Madonna, Edith Piaf, and Nina Simone all at once. I could wax lyrical about how she sounds drunk and angry and glorious and depressed and aroused and high and hung-over and elated within one song. But no amount of reading or writing about Bad Romance could ever do it justice; you just have to listen to it.
Ten Not
10. Little Secrets – Passion Pit
Usually children’s choirs irritate me. But I would forgive this zany electronic jamboree far worse crimes. It is just so happy!
9. Stranger – Noah and the Whale
Charlie Fink has his heart on display throughout the entirety of ‘The First Days of Spring’, the entire album charting his breakup with former band-member Laura Marling. Of all the songs on it, Stranger always lingers in my mind for the lyrical attention to detail backed up by beautiful folksy melodies. ‘Last night I slept with a stranger / for the first time, since you’ve gone’, Fink mournfully recalls, and the song is off, unflinchingly exploring all of the emotional baggage surrounding the encounter.
Noah and the Whale have managed to transform themselves into able story-tellers, each song on the album building into the larger tale whilst managing to stand alone as fully-formed pieces of music. The best part is that Stranger avoids the dangers of wallowing and self-indulgence, achieving a sense a progress through the beautiful five minutes it lasts and delivering some sense of hope by the song’s finish. Voyeurism never felt this good.
8. Damaris – Patrick Wolf
I’ve been a fan of Patrick Wolf for a few years now and I am always impressed by the distinctive sound that he imbues each new record with. Whilst 2009′s ‘The Bachelor’ is not my favourite of his albums (plaudits there go to 2005′s ‘Wind in the Wires’), it is a fine effort, displaying a now typical multitude of new ideas and sounds. Damaris is particularly interesting as Wolf takes on a challenge that he has thus far avoided – sounding epic. Oh, doubtless he has had string-sections and imposing drums aplenty, but here he reaches further than before, here the sound and scope encompasses far more than his already usual orchestral set-up.
The ambitious tone of the song is present on other tracks throughout the album, but Damaris in particular retains the kind of deeply personal narrative that has long been a staple in Wolf’s musical arsenal. For all its ostentatiousness, Damaris could work played on a ukulele by Wolf alone. It wouldn’t surprise me if he tried it.
7. Possibility – Lykke Li
Some music I latch onto for the lyrics, for interpretation and meaning. This song I latch onto because her voice sounds like heartbreak.
6. Young Adult Friction – The Pains Of Being Pure At Heart
The Pains Of Being Pure At Heart are the kind of band you accidentally discover playing a late afternoon slot at a one-day festival. Young Adult Friction is the sort of song that lingers in your mind long after their set is over and everyone has gone home. The sort of song that you end up humming the refrain of for hours without realising what it is. The sort of song that you stick on repeat and churn through your earphones all the way down the road, wishing that every journey could be so competently and buoyantly sound-tracked.
5. Musician, Please Take Heed – God Help The Girl
Oh Stuart Murdoch. You just get it so right, don’t you? This infinitely quotable track stands out in an otherwise slightly inconsistent soundtrack for its sheer craft. Within one song Belle & Sebastian’s front-man deftly ties together a delicate yet flourishing musical aesthetic with the kind of razor-sharp literate story-telling lyrics he has churned out since 1996. A perfect example of Murdoch’s ability to summon up resonant characters and their lives in a few short minutes, something some writers can’t achieve within entire novels.
4. Out of the Don Valley – We Aeronauts
We Aeronauts are the most obscure choice on these two lists – referring to themselves as a ‘marginally signed band’ this eight-piece folk/indie hybrid channel the likes of Okkervil River, Arcade Fire, Broken Social Scene and any other multi-instrumental folk-tinged outfit you’d care to name. Out of the Don Valley is a gorgeous piece of music, built around an intricate instrumental arrangement and heavenly boy-girl harmonies. That something this good was produced by such an (as yet) unknown band excites me to no end.
3. Sea Within A Sea – The Horrors
I feel rather isolated when it comes to the Horrors these days – I actually quite like both of their eras of material. I mostly ignored their debut effort Strange House after one listen, but I do have a fondness for some of the early demos and singles. Nevertheless their new album, particularly closer Sea Within A Sea, is an entirely different entity. An 8 minute long song needs to do a lot to retain my interest, and Sea Within A Sea excels at the task. The Horrors bring a lot to the table; carefully considered layers of sound, excellent pacing, and a sinister lyricism that avoids resorting to hyperbole.
I can see the argument that says it lacks the raw adrenaline of their earlier work, and I hear the assessment that Primary Colours is an altogether more mature, more consistent record. Ultimately, whichever camp you fall into is irrelevant, because Sea Within A Sea is the best thing they’ve ever produced, not least because it now marks the band down as artistically aspiring higher than the top 40 and the cover of the NME.
2. Zero – Yeah Yeah Yeahs
Exciting, giddy and a little bit unhinged, at the end of Zero you collapse back into your chair, run through the past 4.25 minutes in your head and wonder where in the galloping rush of instruments and whooping you can begin to get a hold on what made that sound so good.
What I like about this song, compared to something like Gold Lion for instance, is that Zero is almost a big sprawling mess. Not quite, though, for there is undoubtedly method in the seeming madness of this eclectic affair. Quite what that genius method entails is beyond me, but then again, I couldn’t ever produce a song like Zero.
1. No You Girls – Franz Ferdinand
Five, almost six years on and Franz Ferdinand still work on me. Sexy, flirtatious, and as tight and catchy as anything they’ve ever produced. A song for several occasions, I delight in the different angles you can take on this lyrically. Kapranos is just as easily cast as the wry social observer as the gently amused mediator, and a dozen other roles to boot. Yes, it’s oh so very hip with all the knowing winks and seductive smiles that the band practically trademarked as their own. But fuck it, they are the original and the best, and they never fail to charm me.
And that’s your lot. Thanks for reading, here’s the Spotify playlist.